Contests
Twice a year contest
series are held. In
February, we hold our speech and evaluation contests.
Winners of the club contest go on to compete in the Area 4
contest. Winners at the Area level go on to compete at the Division D
contest. The winners are
the Division level go on to compete at the District 38 contest. Only the winner of the Speech contest goes on to compete at
the Region VII contest. The
Evaluation contest stops at the District level.
The winner at the Region level goes on to compete at the
Toastmasters International Speech contest held some time during the
summer.
Only those members who wish to compete do so.
In order to compete in the speech contest the contestant must be
a Toastmaster in good standing and must have given at least six speeches
in the Basic Manual.
Speech
Contest Scoring
The speech for the speech
contest can be on any subject the contestant desires.
The timing on the speech is five to seven minutes.
That means the contestant is within time if the speech is between
4:30 and 7:30 in length. Speeches
that are outside that range are disqualified.
Speeches are judged by at least five judges and could be as many
as a dozen. The more judges
used, the more fair the outcome. The
judges for the speech contest use the following scoring when judging the
contestants.
Judging
Items
|
Excellent
|
Very
Good
|
Good
|
Fair
|
Speech
Development
Structure,
organization, support material
|
20
|
14-19
|
9-13
|
0-8
|
|
Effectiveness
Achievement
of purpose, interest, reception
|
15
|
11-14
|
6-10
|
0-5
|
Speech
Value
Ideas,
logic, original thought
|
15
|
11-14
|
6-10
|
0-5
|
|
Physical
Appearance
body
language
|
10
|
7-9
|
4-6
|
0-3
|
|
Voice
Flexibility,
volume
|
10
|
7-9
|
4-6
|
0-3
|
|
Manner
Directness,
assurance, enthusiasm
|
10
|
7-9
|
4-6
|
0-3
|
|
Appropriateness
To
speech purpose and audience
|
10
|
7-9
|
4-6
|
0-3
|
|
Correctness
Grammar,
pronunciation, word selection
|
10
|
7-9
|
4-6
|
0-3
|
Each judge rates each speech in the various categories.
Then they add up the total score.
A perfect speech would score 100.
When all the speeches are done, each judge then ranks the speakers,
based on their numerical scores as one, two or three.
They record their rankings on a ballot and then turn them into the
chief judge.
The contestant with the most number one rankings wins the contest.
The chief judge also does the same scoring and keeps his/her ballot
in reserve. Should a tie
occur, the chief judge’s ballot will be used to break the tie.
Evaluation
Contest Scoring
To compete in the Evaluation
contest, the contestant need only be a member in good standing.
In the evaluation contest, a “target” speaker gives a speech.
At the conclusion of the speech, all the evaluation contestants are
given five minutes to analyze the speech and summarize their findings. Their notes are confiscated and they are lead from the room.
Then the contestants are brought back into the room one at a time
and each one gives their evaluation of the target speaker.
As in the Speech contest, the judges give numerical rankings to
various categories for the evaluators.
Here’s how the judges rank the evaluators.
Judging
Items
|
Excellent
|
Very
Good
|
Good
|
Fair
|
Analytical
Quality
Clear,
focused
|
40
|
28-39
|
17-27
|
0-16
|
Recommendations
Positive,
specific, helpful
|
30
|
22-29
|
13-21
|
0-12
|
Technique
Sympathetic,
sensitive, motivational
|
15
|
11-14
|
6-10
|
0-5
|
Summation
Concise,
encouraging
|
15
|
11-14
|
6-10
|
0-5
|
The timing on the evaluation contest is two to three minuets.
That means the contestant is within time if the speech is between
1:30 and 3:30 in length. Evaluations
that are outside that range are disqualified.
The same technique for choosing the winner of the Speech contest is
also used in the Evaluation contest.
Humorous
Speech and
Table Topics Contests
In September the Humorous
Speech and Table Topics Contest series is started.
Like in the Speech and evaluation contests, the winners can
progress through the various levels. The only difference is, this contest series does not progress
beyond the District level. The
District 38 contest is the last stop.
In both these contests, the only requirements for a contestant are
that they must be a Toastmaster in good standing.
Humorous
Speech Contest Scoring
The speech for the speech
contest can be on any subject the contestant desires.
The timing on the speech is five to seven minutes.
That means the contestant is within time if the speech is between
4:30 and 7:30 in length. Speeches
that are outside that range are disqualified.
As in the other contests, the judges give numerical rankings to
various categories for the evaluators.
Here’s how the judges rank the humorous speeches.
Judging
Items
|
Excellent
|
Very
Good
|
Good
|
Fair
|
Speech
Development
Structure,
organization, body, support material
|
15
|
11-14
|
6-10
|
0-9
|
|
Effectiveness
Excitement
created, the unexpected twist, surprise, connection of humorous
events, achievement of purpose
|
10
|
7-9
|
4-6
|
0-5
|
Speech
Value
Ideas,
originality of thought and material
|
15
|
11-14
|
6-10
|
0-9
|
|
Audience
Response
Attentiveness,
laughter, interest, reception
|
15
|
11-14
|
6-10
|
0-9
|
|
Physical Appearance
body
language
|
10
|
7-9
|
4-6
|
0-5
|
|
Voice
Flexibility,
volume
|
10
|
7-9
|
4-6
|
0-5
|
|
Manner
Directness,
assurance, enthusiasm
|
10
|
7-9
|
4-6
|
0-5
|
|
Appropriateness
To
speech purpose and audience, reflecting good taste
|
10
|
7-9
|
4-6
|
0-5
|
|
Correctness
Grammar,
pronunciation, word selection (use of dialect, vernacular)
|
5
|
4
|
3
|
0-2
|
Table
Topics Contest Scoring
In the Table Topics contest,
the contestants are escorted from the room and then brought back into the
room one at a time. Each
contestant is given the same table topic on which to speak.
The contestant must then speak on the subject without any
preparation.
The timing on the table topics is one to two minutes.
That means the contestant is within time if the speech is between
0:30 and 2:30 in length. Speeches
that are outside that range are disqualified.
As in the other contests, the judges give numerical rankings to
various categories for the evaluators.
Here’s how the judges rank the table topics speeches.
Judging
Items
|
Excellent
|
Very
Good
|
Good
|
Fair
|
Speech
Development
Opening,
body, close, organization, smoothness
|
30
|
23-29
|
17-22
|
0-16
|
|
Effectiveness
Logic,
directness, enthusiasm, achievement of purpose, audience response
|
25
|
18-24
|
11-17
|
0-10
|
Physical
Appearance,
body language
|
15
|
11-14
|
6-10
|
0-5
|
|
Voice
Flexibility,
volume
|
15
|
11-14
|
6-10
|
0-5
|
|
Language
Appropriate
to speech, purpose and audience. Good grammar, pronunciation, and word selection
|
15
|
11-14
|
6-10
|
0-5
|
Boardwalk
Toastmasters, Ocean City, New Jersey. Building eloquent speakers
from the terrified and the tongue tied.
|